I think I liked it. I watched it to see what the hype was about. I watched it so I could partake in a possible office conversation the following morning. I watched it expecting to see Shatner flounder, to see forced diatribe from a fake, grumpy old man. I also watched hoping to see that they were able to create something worth watching. It’s a rather ambitious task to create a successful series based on roughly 200 quotes, each 140 characters or less.
I’d say that over the 22 minutes of comedy, I laughed audibly five times. Three were with some force behind them – they were breath ejected with forceful surprise to the pleasantly unexpected. The other two were moderately delayed chuckles as I put the scene together, took into account what we knew about the characters, where the dialogue was going, and what I expected to see happen but quickly realized instead, “hey, that was pretty funny. I liked that”.
I’m all for giving things time. To use once again, an overly used metaphor, comedy is like a nice red wine – it needs to breath. Like the wine, whose tannins need to mix with the oxygen in the air, the characters in a comedy need to develop, the plot lines need to form, and the two need to meet, mix and combine in a way that creates a unified entity. I’m not saying every show on the air would be a success if given time, but there are a few that deserve that ability. Could you imagine if we had to base all life’s relationships from a 22 minute meet-and-greet? What are the odds that in that time you would learn that both you and this relative stranger were in the Greek islands at the exact same time, that you stayed at hotels just down the street, and that you both had a super awkward exchange with that guy outside that one restaurant with the teal awning. You wouldn’t. These are things that you learn in time. Things that make the person all that much more interesting.
So there you have it, let’s watch to see whether the strained yet loving relationship between Shatner and his kid proves endearing or repetitively annoying. Let’s watch to see if the ‘grizzled old dad’ and ‘bumbling young adult’ dynamic is a sustainable one or if the “you’re stuck in your ways old man…yeah, well you have no direction in life, kid” jokes wear thin. Let’s watch to see.